A Flaw in Hebraic Roots
End-Times Doctrine
- Appendix 5 -
Note:
In Appendix 4 - The Subtle Demise of True Christianity -
the tragic
results of rejecting or even neglecting the constitution of our faith,
the Torah, and its author Yahuah was described.
However, there
is another side of that coin: Many Messianic Believers, in trying so
hard to be Torah-observant Hebrews, neglect their Renewed
Covenant relationship with the Messiah Yahushua and thus ruin their
witness both to Jews and to Christians. The following essay explains
how our understanding of our life in the Messiah and our relationship to
His People applies to our interpretation of End-Times Bible prophecy.
I
am eternally grateful to Yahuah for opening my eyes to the Hebraic
roots of my faith. There is no way that I could fully or correctly
interpret prophetic Scripture without some understanding of the
language, religion, and culture of the writers of Bible prophecy.
However, there is a flaw in the doctrine of many Hebraic Roots
teachers and Believers that is causing confusion in their understanding
of Yahuah’s plan for His People at the End of the Age. Few Hebraic
Roots teachers seem to acknowledge the clear distinction between
Yahuah’s plan for His physical People, those of the twelve tribes of
Israel who will not recognize that Yahushua is the Messiah until He
returns at the End of the Age, and His plan for those Jews and Gentiles
who have already come to faith in the Messiah Yahushua.
Most (not all) Hebraic Roots Believers and teachers think that all
of Israel, including those grafted into her through faith in Yahushua,
will be brought physically out of the Gentile nations back into the Land
of Israel at the End of the Age, then, after being reunited as the
twelve tribes of the nation of Israel, will inhabit the restored earth
in their mortal, physical bodies during the millennial reign of the
Messiah Yahushua.
However, Scripture clearly reveals that there will be
two categories of the Redeemed of Yahuah during the Millennium -
those who have already trusted in Yahushua as their Savior and Messiah before the sounding of the “Last Trump”
on Yom Teruah (those who are under the Renewed Covenant), and those
physical descendants of the twelve tribes of Israel who will not
recognize that Yahushua is the Messiah until He returns in the
clouds on that day (those who are still living under Yahuah's original
covenant with Israel). And Yahuah’s plan for those two groups of Saints
at the End of the Age and during the millennial reign of the Messiah
(albeit not throughout eternity) are very different.
Most
Hebraic Roots teachers take numerous passages of Scripture out of
context, misinterpret them, and misapply them to support their doctrine
that all of Israel, including the Gentiles grafted in through
faith in Yahushua, will be brought physically out of the nations at the
End of the Age into the Land and established there as the spiritual and physical Kingdom of Yahuah.
An example of a misinterpreted passage is Zechariah 8:23, which states, “In those days
ten men from every language of the nations shall grasp the sleeve of a
Jewish man, saying, ‘Let us go with you, for we have heard that [Yahuah]
is with you.’”
Most Hebraic Roots teachers assert that “those days”
refers to the End of the Age, when the Lord will gather His People
Israel out of the nations into the Land.
However, just a cursory
examination of the text reveals that this passage is referring to what
will happen during the millennial reign of the Messiah, after Israel is
reestablished in the Land and is surrounded by nations made up of
descendants of Yahuah-fearing Gentiles who did not come to faith in
Yahushua prior to the Millennium, but who were allowed to enter the
millennial Messianic kingdom because they favored and helped the Jews
during the Great Tribulation and never took the mark of the beast.
During the Millennium, according to the prophecy of Ezekiel 40-48, the
twelve tribes of Israel will be reestablished in the Land and will have a
favored place in the Land, just as they did in the land of Goshen in
Egypt when Joseph (a type of the Messiah) was the Prince of Egypt. And,
during the Millennium (not during the Great Tribulation at the End of
the Age), the surrounding Gentile nations will see that Israel is
blessed by Yahuah and will want to share in her prosperity. But, to
partake of Israel’s prosperity, the Gentiles must observe the feast days
and Torah of Yahuah. Those who fail to keep the Torah,
and to go up to Jerusalem year after year to keep the feast days and
worship the King, will perish during the thousand years (cf. Zechariah
14:16-19), or will be among those who will be deceived into following
Satan when he is released from the bottomless pit at the end of the
thousand years, only to be destroyed by fire from Heaven (cf. 20:8, 9).
But
this understanding of the End-of-the-Age and the Millennium scenarios
begs the question, “If they do not return to the Land of Israel with the
twelve tribes, what will happen to those who have previously (before
the end of the Final Seven Years) accepted Yahushua as the Messiah (the
Renewed Covenant Saints)?” does it not? Again, Scripture is clear to
those who have their doctrinal ducks in order and their spiritual eyes
open to the Truth: At the end of the Final Seven Years, the wrath of
Satan (the “Great Tribulation”) will be interrupted (cf. Matthew
24:22) by the awesome events of Yom Teruah (the Feast of Trumpets), when
the Messiah will return to gather those who have already believed in
Him, catch them up to meet Him in the air, and take them to New
Jerusalem (which is still in Heaven), until Yahuah has finished pouring
out His “last plagues” (15:1), the bowls of wrath, on the earth
dwellers during the ten Days of Awe. Then, after the marriage in Heaven
of the Lamb to His Bride (the Body of Believers in Him) and His
coronation as King of kings and Lord of lords, the armies of Heaven
(including angels and the redeemed, glorified Saints) will return with
King Yahushua on Yom Kippur (the Day of Atonement) to destroy His
enemies, save the Redeemed of Israel (who had looked on Him whom they
had pierced, repented, and accepted Him as their Messiah and King when
He returned in the clouds on Yom Teruah), pour out His Spirit on them
(Zechariah 12:10), and establish His millennial kingdom on earth. The
glorified, Renewed Covenant Saints will then rule with the Messiah over
the tribes of Israel and the surrounding nations from their thrones in
New Jerusalem (which has descended from Heaven—21:1). (cf. Matthew
19:28; 2 Timothy 2:12; Revelation 2:27; 20:4).
However, contrary to this Scriptural scenario, some of the more
popular Hebraic Roots teachers (Bill Cloud, Perry Stone, Jim Staley, et
al.), ironically, teach a Hebraic Roots version of Replacement
Theology, asserting that those Gentiles who come to faith in Yahushua
are actually literal Hebrews of the Northern Kingdom of Israel (the “ten
lost tribes”) who will be brought back into the Land and reunited with
the tribes of the Southern Kingdom (mainly the tribe of Judah) who are
already in the Land and who will not come to faith in Yahushua until the
Final Seven Years. In other words, according to this doctrine, the
“Jews” who do not yet believe that Yahushua is the Messiah are in a
different category - they are not yet the People of Yahuah in the same
sense that those “Hebrew Gentiles” (an oxymoron) are. This
“two-sticks-becoming-one-man” doctrine, which asserts that only the
tribes of the Northern Kingdom (consisting of the Hebrew Gentiles) will
be brought out of the nations back into the Land, but that the tribes of
the Southern Kingdom have never been divorced by Yahuah and exiled from
the Land - they have just been temporarily blinded to who He is - is
based on erroneous interpretations of Ezekiel 37:16-22, Romans Chapter
11, and Ephesians Chapter 2.
Scripture correctly interpreted, however, proves this doctrine
false.
A basic reason for its error is in making a false, unscriptural
distinction between the House of Ephraim and the House of Judah,
stating
that the Northern Kingdom was divorced by Yahuah, banished into the
Gentile nations of the world and absorbed by those nations, making them
“Hebrew Gentiles.”
But, according to this doctrine,
the tribes of the
Southern Kingdom have never been divorced by Yahuah and dispersed into
the nations, so have not become Gentiles.
But, I would submit, that
interpretation is incorrect according to sound exegesis.
Yes, the
Northern Kingdom was divorced by Yahuah because of idolatry, but history
tells us that, although as a political entity the Northern Kingdom was
destroyed, not all of the ten “northern” tribes were carried away by the
Assyrians.
Entire tribes remained intact in the land. In fact,
although ten tribes rebelled against the Torah and practiced
idolatry, Simeon was located within the boundaries of the Southern
Kingdom,
so was not geographically a “northern” tribe at all. Part of
the tribe of Dan was also located within the boundaries of the Southern
Kingdom.
Also, when the Assyrians invaded the Northern Kingdom,
multitudes fled to the Southern Kingdom. The population of Jerusalem
increased five-fold because of the influx of refugees from the north.
And the tribes that were taken away by the Assyrians remained pretty
much intact for many years in the lands in which they were relocated.
And today, there are groups of people all over the world who are still
keeping the Torah, or at least remnants of the Torah, who
either claim to be or studies have shown them to be descendants of the
nine (not ten) northern tribes.
And now, DNA studies are further
confirming that many of these modern Israelites are indeed descended
from or are at least partially descended from various tribes of Israel,
including both the “northern” and southern tribes.
Yes, Hosea 1:6, 7 states that Yahuah will . . . “utterly take them [the House of Israel] away. Yet I will have mercy on the house of Judah . . .”
But obviously, that was a Hebraic hyperbole that meant the House of
Ephraim/Israel, as a political and geographical entity, would be
destroyed and scattered.
It did not mean that the individual Israelites
or even the tribes would be absorbed by the nations of the world to the
point of totally losing their identities and even becoming Gentiles.
Also, although Yahuah had mercy on the House of Judah and did not
divorce them at that time, they were not blameless before the Lord, were
they? Please notice that in Hosea Chapter 3 the focus of the
indictment for spiritual adultery generalizes to the whole nation of
Israel (the “children of Israel”) rather than applying just to the “House of Israel”
(Ephraim).
And more is said about how the entire nation of Israel was
guilty of idolatry from the time they came out of Egypt in 11:1, 2.
So,
although the book of Hosea addresses primarily the unfaithfulness of
the House of Israel and their consequent rejection by Yahuah, and His
sparing of the House of Judah because they had not yet rebelled
against Him as had the House of Israel,
about 120 years after the
Northern Kingdom was destroyed, the tribes of the Southern Kingdom also
rejected the Torah and broke the covenant, just as had those of
the Northern Kingdom.
And just as happened to the House of Ephraim,
beginning in about 606 BCE, the House of Judah (which consisted of
members not just of the tribe of Judah, but of all 12 tribes) was
carried away into captivity into Babylon. Then, please note, 70 years
later, only a small remnant returned to the Land of Israel and rebuilt
the Temple and Jerusalem. The vast majority remained in Babylon and
other places to which they had migrated. And what did those Jews who
had come back into the Land of Israel do in 29 CE? They totally
rejected the Living Torah - the Messiah - didn’t they? And what
happened to them? Just as had happened to the House of Ephraim, they
were scattered (in 70 and 135 CE) all over the world. So, exactly as
was prophesied (Isa 50:1), both houses of Israel were divorced by Yahuah.
So what, really, is the difference between the Northern Kingdom and
the Southern Kingdom today? I submit to you that, at the present time,
there is ZERO difference - ZILCH! They are both members of the cultivated olive tree that have been cut off (Romans 11). They have both
been scattered all over the world until the Lord gathers them out of
the nations back into the land, where, when they see Him return in the
clouds at the end of the Final Seven Years, on Yom Teruah at the
sounding of the seventh and “last trumpet” (1 Corinthians 15:52; Revelation 11:15), will mourn because they will then recognize that their Messiah and King is the Torah
they have both rejected and the one they pierced (Zechariah 12:10;
Revelation 1:7) (in a spiritual sense, we have all rejected and pierced
the Messiah). So, it will be at that time - at the end of the seven years (and not before) - that the physical descendants of Israel - all 12 tribes
- will repent, accept Yahushua as their Messiah and King, and be saved.
There is absolutely no reason to interpret Ezekiel 37:16-22 in any
other way than the plain, literal way in which it was written - as
referring to the physical descendants of Israel - all 12 tribes
- being separated and dispersed into the world, then coming back
together at the End of the Age. To say that it refers only to the House
of Ephraim is a forced, inconsistent interpretation that is
disingenuous, to say the least. Please read Ezekiel 37:21-22 carefully
and honestly:
Surely I will take the children of Israel [not just the House of Ephraim or the House of Judah] from among the nations, wherever they have gone, and will gather them [the children of Israel] from every side and bring them into their own land; and I will make them [the children of Israel] one nation in the land, on the mountains of Israel; and one king shall be king over them all [the children of Israel]; they shall no longer be two nations, nor shall they ever be divided into two kingdoms again.
And please notice that the terms “children of Israel,” “one nation,” “two nations,” and “two kingdoms” all refer to all 12 tribes of Israel. The term “children of Israel” appears over 2,000 times in the Bible, and it always refers to all 12 tribes of Israel - never to just the Northern or Southern Kingdom.
But the teachers of the Hebrew Gentile doctrine insist that it was only the tribes of the Northern Kingdom, the House of Ephraim/Israel, who were divorced by Yahuah and dispersed among the Gentile nations. And, they assert, at the End of the Age, it will be only the Hebrew Gentiles who are brought out of the nations back into the Land. And who, specifically, are the Hebrew Gentiles according to this doctrine? They are those who have already accepted Yeshua as their Savior and Messiah. They are the branches of the wild olive tree who have been grafted into the natural olive tree, Israel (Romans 11:17), and have been made “fellow citizens” in the “commonwealth” of Israel (Ephesians 2:12, 19). And, according to this doctrine, this grafting-in process will continue until “the fullness of the [Hebrew] Gentiles has come in” (Romans 11:25).
But the teachers of the Hebrew Gentile doctrine insist that it was only the tribes of the Northern Kingdom, the House of Ephraim/Israel, who were divorced by Yahuah and dispersed among the Gentile nations. And, they assert, at the End of the Age, it will be only the Hebrew Gentiles who are brought out of the nations back into the Land. And who, specifically, are the Hebrew Gentiles according to this doctrine? They are those who have already accepted Yeshua as their Savior and Messiah. They are the branches of the wild olive tree who have been grafted into the natural olive tree, Israel (Romans 11:17), and have been made “fellow citizens” in the “commonwealth” of Israel (Ephesians 2:12, 19). And, according to this doctrine, this grafting-in process will continue until “the fullness of the [Hebrew] Gentiles has come in” (Romans 11:25).
In other words, the terms “Hebrew Gentiles” and “Christians”
are, essentially, synonymous. Both the "Hebrew Gentiles" and the
Christians are Believers in Yeshua. And like most Christians, most of
the teachers of the Hebrew Gentile doctrine see themselves as separate
from and therefore, by implication, spiritually superior to those Jews
who have not yet accepted Yahushua as their Savior and Lord.
The only
differences between "Hebrew Gentiles" and Christians are that "Hebrew
Gentiles" have (allegedly) embraced their Hebraic roots and believe that
they are, literally, descendants of the tribes of the House of Ephraim.
No wonder popular Hebraic Roots teachers like Perry Stone, Bill Cloud,
and Jim Staley are finding warm acceptance in many Christian churches
and their ministries are prospering here in America-Babylon.
However, there are several serious problems with the Hebrew Gentile doctrine:
- In their teachings, those who espouse that doctrine have to do some pretty fancy dancing through the Scriptures to maintain their premise that, at the present time, the Northern Kingdom is divorced by Yahuah and have, in fact, become Gentiles, but the Southern Kingdom has not been divorced by the Lord. For example, it is almost comical (if it weren’t such a serious error) to see them, in their exposition of Romans 9-11 (which contains the name “Israel” 13 times) jumping back and forth between asserting that “Israel” refers to the Southern Kingdom in some verses but to the Northern Kingdom in others. Obviously, throughout his letter to the Romans, Paul is using the terms “Jews” and “Israel” interchangeably to refer to the whole nation - all 12 tribes.
- (Referring to the whole nation of Israel as “Jews” began after the destruction of the Northern Kingdom, and Judah, the royal tribe from whom the Ruler who would sit on David’s throne would come and the only remaining intact, identifiable tribe, came to represent the entire nation—cf. Dan 1:3; 9:7, 11, 20).
- Another
example of a forced interpretation, unsupported by Scripture, is their
mistranslation and bad exegesis of 1 Peter 1:1, 2:
Peter, an apostle of [Yahushua the Messiah], to the strangers scattered throughout Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, elect according to the foreknowledge of [Yahuah] the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit, unto obedience and sprinkling of the blood of [Yahushua the Messiah]: Grace unto you, and peace, be multiplied.
They state that Peter is writing to the “lost tribes” of the Northern Kingdom, who are identified as Gentiles, - explaining that the Hebrew word for “strangers” is Goyim ("Gentiles").
- But, that is just flat not true.
- The Greek word that is normally translated “Gentiles” in the B’rit Hadashah is ethnos.
- But the word translated “strangers” in 1 Peter 1:1 is parepidimos, which Strong’s (3927) defines as: “one who comes from a foreign country into a city or land to reside there by the side of the natives.”
- In other words, the dispersed ones to whom Peter was writing were indeed descendants of the tribes of Israel, but they had definitely not been absorbed into the nations and become Gentiles.
- A third example of trying to force the interpretation to fit the premise is in stating that in Yeshua’s statement to the Canaanite woman,
- “I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel” (Matthew 15:24),
- He was referring to the northern tribes.
- But wasn’t His personal ministry entirely to the tribes of the Southern Kingdom, which, according to the Hebrew Gentile interpretation, would be excluded by His statement to the Canaanite woman?
- And in His command to His disciples to take the Gospel to the “lost sheep of the house of Israel,” didn’t He pointedly tell them not to go to the Gentiles, or even to the Samaritans (Matthew 10:5)?
- How does these teachers’ notion that the lost tribes are Gentiles jive with that?
- A fourth example of incorrect exegesis is the assertion that the grafting of the (Hebrew) Gentiles into the “commonwealth” of Israel is a literal grafting into the physical nation of Israel.
- However, an honest examination of the text reveals that this graft is not literal but spiritual. The Gentiles are grafted, “contrary to nature” (Romans 11:24), into the “natural” olive tree (Israel).
- In other words, those grafted-in Gentiles are not
natural, physical Hebrews at all. They are the spiritual, not
physical, seed of Abraham through faith in the natural seed of Abraham,
Yahushua. (Jews who look forward in faith to the coming Messiah but who
do not yet recognize that He is Yahushua are the spiritual and physical seed of Abraham.) Also, the term “commonwealth” does not refer to the literal, physical nation of Israel. Gerhard Kittel’s Theological Dictionary of the New Testament points out that the Greek word politeia, translated “commonwealth” in Ephesians 2:12,
does not mean civil rights, constitution, or state, [but] rather the pious order of life which, ordained by the Law of Moses, is inherited from the fathers. [With one exception it] is a religious and moral concept rather than a political concept; it denotes the “walk” determined by the Mosaic Law. (Volume 6, p. 526)
Then, David Stern, in his Jewish New Testament Commentary, states that politeia . . .implies an obligation to observe a godly way of life that has its origin in God’s relationship with the Jewish people . . . [and] an obligation to relate as family to the Jewish community to whom [the grafted-in Gentiles’] faith has joined them. (p. 582)
In other words, “fellow citizens” in the “commonwealth of Israel” refers to sharing the familial, spiritual covenant relationship that Israel has with Yehovah, not to a literal, physical grafting into the nation of Israel. - Other indications that Ephesians Chapter 2 is speaking of spiritual and figurative rather than physical and literal realities are the statements that Yahuah has “raised us up together, and made us sit together in the heavenly places in [the Messiah Yahushua]” (verse 6) and, the Messiah has abolished the wall of separation between the Jews and Gentiles, creating in Himself “one new man from the two” (verses 14 and 15).
- Then, the apostle Paul confirms that the grafting into Israel is spiritual rather than physical when He states, “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in [the Messiah Yahushua]" (Galatians 3:28).
- Another handle onto which the teachers of the Hebrew Gentile doctrine attempt to grab to support their interpretation is the prophetic promise through Jacob that the descendants of his grandson Ephraim would become a “multitude of nations" (Greek: goyim) (Genesis 48:19).
- And they assert that the phrase “fullness of the [grafted-in] Gentiles” in Romans 11:25 is equivalent to “multitude of nations.”
- However, as was explained in detail in Appendix 3 - Who are the People of Yahuah? - the Greek term goy (plural: goyim) is translated simply “nation(s),”
- and can refer to either Hebrew or Gentile nations, depending on the context. So, the promise to Ephraim looked forward to the multitude of Hebrew (not Gentile) nations - the descendants of Ephraim - during the Millennium. But the phrase “fullness of the Gentiles” in Romans 11:25 refers to Gentiles who are (spiritually) grafted into Israel.
So,
it would seem that these teachers’ distinction between the two houses
of Israel is purely arbitrary and contrived, based on misinterpreted
Scripture, to support their view that “true Israel” (Romans 9:6) is
comprised of those “Hebrew Gentiles” of the Northern Kingdom who have
been grafted into the cultivated olive tree, but the Jews of the
Southern Kingdom are not quite there yet. And sadly, it is at that
point that subtle anti-Semitism and Replacement Theology are injected
into their teachings.
The present-day, Torah-observant Jews (including those physical descendants of both
the House of Ephraim and the House of Judah) who believe in Yehovah and
look forward in faith to the coming Messiah, although they have not yet
recognized that He is Yahushua, are no less the chosen People of Yahuah
than were the Torah-observant ancient patriarchs and Israelites,
beginning with Abraham, who believed in Yehovah and looked forward in
faith to the coming Messiah. Or, are the teachers of the Hebrew Gentile
doctrine going to insist that Abraham, Moses, Joseph, Elijah and all
the other great people of faith in ancient Israel were not “true Israel”
and are not saved because they did not accept Yahushua as their
Messiah?
Yes, many thousands - perhaps millions - of Jews (beginning
with those of the House of Judah) of both the Northern and Southern
Kingdoms have come to faith in Yahushua, but I submit to you that most
of them have not. However, in the end, all of "true Israel" (the
physical descendants of Jacob who believe in Yahuah and look forward in
faith to the coming Messiah, whether or not they have, at the present
time, recognized that He is Yahushua), will be saved (Romans 11:26).
In
the eyes of Yahuah, who sees the whole mural of history from beginning
to end, the ones who are saved - past, present, and future - have been
chosen from the beginning - “elect according to the foreknowledge of [Yehovah]” (1 Peter 1:2).
So, who are we to say that only the ones who accept Yahushua as their Messiah before
He gathers them out of the nations into the Land are, at the present
time, His redeemed Elect?
Who are we to say that those of physical
Israel who will not recognize that their Messiah and King is Yeshua until
He returns in the clouds at the end of the Final Seven Years, and, at
that time, look on Him whom they have pierced and mourn (Zechariah
12:10; Revelation 1:7), are not just as much the People of Yahuah as
those Renewed Covenant Believers who have already accepted Him as
their Messiah and Savior?
Because they have been temporarily blinded
to who the Messiah is, they have not yet come into the full Renewed
Covenant relationship with Him, but as soon as the blinders have been
removed when He returns in the clouds on a soon-coming Yom Teruah, the
Spirit of Yahuah will fall on them just as it did on the Believers on
Shavuot following the Lord Yahushua’s resurrection and ascension, and
they too will be Renewed Covenant People of Yahuah (cf. Joel 2:28;
Zechariah 12:10; Acts 2:3-18).
So, as the apostle Paul warned us (Romans 11:25), let us not,
whether we are Messianic or Christian Believers in Yahushua, look down
our noses at those Jews who believe in Yahuah and look forward in faith
to the coming Messiah,
although they have not yet recognized that He is
Yahushua. Their blindness to His identity is temporary, and, although
they will have a different role in the Messianic Kingdom than we do,
they are just as much the beloved children of Yahuah as we are. And, in
Timeless Eternity following the Millennium (see Appendix 8 - How Long is "Forever" in the Bible),
there will be no distinction between Israel and the Gentile nations or
between glorified and physical Saints. We will all be one in union with
the Messiah Yahushua (Galatians 3:28).
For more details and
Scriptural support of the above End Times scenario, please read this
commentary on the Revelation Chapters 7, 11 and 19-21.
No comments:
Post a Comment